[ros-dev] Maybe Its All About Nothing

Ge van Geldorp gvg at reactos.com
Fri Dec 3 12:50:07 CET 2004


> From: Thomas Larsen
> 
> Hi Guys lots of talk about ekubush
> and their cloning of your project but seems to me that u
> allso clone some (very much) stuff from from both Windows 
> 2000 and Windows NT 4.0 Scsiport.sys and alot of shell32 code 
> and NTOSKRNL.exe are taking direct out of Windows Code

Why do you think a lot of code in scsiport.sys, shell32.dll and ntoskrnl.exe
were copied from Windows? Although I didn't personally write all the code in
the components you mention, I'm confident that it wasn't copied from Windows
but written from scratch. BTW, most of the shell32 code was copied from
Wine, so if you accuse us of copyright infringement you're also accusing
Wine of copyright infringement.

> seems 
> to be to a good base idea to maybe get some idea about the 
> internal stuff in both Directx and Ddraw.dll and the 
> hardcoded stuff works but Microsoft will close the Project if 
> anyone from their department finds out. the opdates in the 
> last past has just been want microsoft

Sorry, no clue what you mean here.

> Does find some 
> mistakes where i look a the xx and the same mistakes 
> microsoft did is about something like
> 
> void
> Somefunction(LPWSTR SomeString)
> {
>  return NT(LPWSTR SomeString); where it should LPSTR..
> }

Please provide specific references, examples of exactly which functions you
claim were copied from Windows.

> And guys i wanna make a better Reactos Not the same shit 
> microsoft do... hope you will to now maybe i should go for 
> myself now.... and make a new Windows Project..
> 
> And if you do clone Windows Code please do it a littel better 
> than that

If you can backup your claims with proof, please show us the proof. If you
can't show any proof, please go back to working for SCO.

Ge van Geldorp.




More information about the Ros-dev mailing list